News tips and press releases may be sent
to editor at hollywoodinvestigator.com.
All submissions become property of the Hollywood Investigator and
deemed for publication without compensation unless otherwise
requested. Name and contact information only withheld upon request.
Prospective reporters should research our
Bookstore.
by Thomas M. Sipos,
managing editor [October 11, 2020]
[HollywoodInvestigator.com]Some people might watch
Proxima
(2019) expecting science fiction. They will be disappointed. It's
actually about a woman astronaut training for a mission aboard the
International Space Station, while simultaneously coping with the
problems of single motherhood. Imagine a Lifetime Channel movie with a
bigger budget. Even so,
Proxima is a diverting albeit unexceptional film, but for the
bizarre plot twist near the end, which arguably subverts that film's
feminist message -- especially in our Covid crazy era.
The film begins with Sarah (Eva Green) telling her ex-husband, Thomas
(Lars Eidinger), that she has been chosen as one of three astronauts
for a year-long mission on the ISS. Sarah needs Thomas to look after
their daughter, Stella (Zelie Boulant), while Sarah's in space. Most
of the film is about her training for the mission. The film ends when
she blasts off into space.
Proxima is interesting for its peek into the world of astronaut
training. But its drama doesn't stem primarily from the training
scenes. The focus of the story is the mother and daughter's impending
separation. Stella is a shy little girl. She'll miss her mom. She
dreads changing schools to live with her dad. What if she makes no
friends?
Proxima pays homage to the usual feminist cliches, but with gentle
taps rather than a sledge hammer. Men are deprecated, but not
demonized. Dad doesn't want to be burdened with the kid, but he easily
relents and does a decent job. Sarah suffers some sexism from Mike
(Matt Dillon), a fellow astronaut, who says there's no shame were
Sarah to take a lighter course load. Sarah smiles politely and gamely
says that she'll stick to the full schedule (same as the men). When
Mike assures Sarah that he's not implying that she's "a space
tourist," she knows that's exactly what he means.
Naturally, Sarah proves to be better than the men. While spinning in a
centrifugal machine, she keeps insisting they increase the
gravitational pull by another G. When she's at 9G, she asks to be
taken to 10G, but the trainers think she's had enough. It's higher
than was scheduled (i.e., than what the men had endured). Sarah is
also a monster on the treadmill. When her heart rate increases to 180,
the trainer tells her to stop, but Sarah wants to keep going. On a
training mission she is the first to exit the capsule, by herself,
whereupon, the observer tells us, she is now "helping" the men to
exit.
Sarah is also magnanimous. A common cliche in old horror/sci-fi films
is that whenever a woman runs from a monster, she'll trip and sprain
her ankle. The hero (a man) then carries and rescues her.
Proxima
reverses the cliche. Sarah, Mike, and Anton (Aleksey Fateev) are doing
laps in the forest. Mike trips and sprains his ankle. Just then,
Sarah's phone rings. It's their superiors, asking the three astronauts
how they're doing. A quick glance between Sarah and Mike. Sarah says
they're all fine, sparing Mike later public embarrassment to his male
ego. Mike nods his appreciation.
Throughout her
training, Sarah talks to Stella, usually over the phone. Stella has a
bad cold. Sarah is not there. Stella is sad because she has no
friends. Sarah's heart breaks. Stella visits the training center in
Russia. But Sarah is focused on her work. Stella is bored and leaves
the building, into the Russian night. Sarah discovers Stella is
missing! A panicked search! Mike has found Stella! Thank God!
It's not easy being an astronaut and a single mother.
Screenplay instructors say there should be a dramatic crisis/turning
point near the middle of every film.
Proxima follows this rule. At the halfway point, Sarah has an
emotional breakdown. She tells Thomas that
"It's too hard." Not the brainy or brawny stuff. Sarah is
brilliant and strong. But the matters of the heart. Leaving Stella.
But as with all things
Proxima, the crisis is minor and easily resolved. Thomas tells
Sarah, "You said you wanted a bicycle. Now ride it." And with
that pep talk, Sarah regains her confidence and resolve. She wanted to
be an astronaut, dammit, and that's just what she's gonna do!
Then comes the glaring error that subverts the whole film.
It's a few days before the launch. Sarah was to meet and hug Stella
one last time before liftoff. But Stella's plane was delayed. By the
time Stella arrives, the astronauts are in quarantine. Sarah and
Stella place their hands against the glass. But they cannot touch.
Stella is sad. Her mom promised they would see the rocket together.
She promised. Sarah's heart breaks.
That night, Sarah breaks quarantine. She sneaks out of the building.
Escapes from the gated, high security compound. Goes to the Stella's
hotel. Thomas, an astrophysicist who knows better, is surprised to see
his ex-wife breaking quarantine, but without protest, hands over their
daughter. Sarah drives Stella to the rocket site. A tender moment as
mother and daughter gaze upon the rocket that will take Sarah into
space.
Sarah returns Stella to Thomas, sneaks back into the gated, high
security compound, into the building, unseen. Takes a long shower with
disinfectant. That's so we know that Sarah is responsible, careful to
avoid infecting the crew with any germs she might have picked up.
Hey, if that's all that's required -- why the quarantine?
How to interpret this scene? That the "male chauvinists" were right
all along? Women can't be trusted in jobs meant for men. They're too
emotional. They won't perform with equal professionalism. They'd
really be happier at home with the kids.
Or are we to think that man-made rules shouldn't apply to women?
Either because women know better; the current rules are bunk,
established solely to keep women out. Or because current rules are not
fair to women; even if the rules make sense, society must accommodate
women's unique needs with new rules.
The rules have already been relaxed for Sarah. We learn that
astronauts normally cut their hair before flights, but Sarah tells a
reporter that it's only because it's more convenient, not because it's
necessary. Sarah has elected to keep her hair long. Sarah also elects
to eschew drugs that would stop her menstruating while in space,
despite the inconvenience.
But breaking quarantine hours before a flight is beyond inconvenient,
no? Does it not endanger the entire crew and mission? As it happens,
Sarah is not caught. The film treats her action not as a selfish,
irresponsible, unprofessional breach of protocol -- but as an
empowering assertion of a career woman's love for her daughter.
Many message films (which
Proxima is) have a key line, a philosophical soundbite, that's
repeated in all the marketing. Here Mike says to Sarah, "There's
no such thing as a perfect astronaut. Just like there's no such thing
as a perfect mother." It's the philosophy of women's daytime TV
and pop psychology. Feel guilty about leaving your kids while you go
to work? Don't! Those stay-at-home moms aren't so perfect.
Guilty that your male colleagues put in longer hours at the office?
Don't! Those men aren't so perfect. Your imperfections
define you -- celebrate them!
Screen Daily calls
Proxima"a feminist masterpiece." Yet in the end, Sarah proves unable
to suppress her emotions and meet masculine standards of
professionalism. To which progressives would reply, so what? Women
should not be judged by "masculine standards of professionalism."
The debate might end at that impasse -- between progressive "gender
feminists" and conservative "equity feminists," but for Covid-19.
Proxima might have seemed a good idea when it was released in
2019. But 2020 imposes a new reading onto the film. In 2020,
progressives treat people without masks like
mass murderers. The maskless have been physically assaulted. But
if taking a walk outdoors without a mask is a deadly threat, how much
more serious to break quarantine -- without a mask! -- hours before
spending an entire year sealed in a tiny space station?
Proxima does end on a powerful note. A crowd watches the rocket
blast off. A quick cut to Sarah, smiling in the capsule. Then back to
the crowd. A long moment as we watch the rocket rising, rising,
rising, until it's a tiny speck of light. Then nothing. We watch the
crowd disperse. We watch Stella go home. We never see Sarah again. She
is gone. These final shots effectively convey how distant and
unreachable the astronauts feel to those left behind on Earth.
The end credits play over a series of photos of historical female
astronauts and cosmonauts, posing with their children. To honor the
"real life" Sarahs. But I'm guessing that none of these astronauts
broke quarantine to be with their kids. So are they really honored by
being represented by Sarah?
"Hollywood Investigator" and
"HollywoodInvestigator.com" and "Tabloid
Witch" and "Tabloid Witch Award" trademarks are
currently unregistered, but pending registration upon need for
protection against improper use. The idea of marketing these terms as a
commodity is a protected idea under the Lanham Act. 15 U.S.C. s 1114(1)
(1994) (defining a trademark infringement claim when the plaintiff has a
registered mark); 15 U.S.C. s 1125(a) (1994) (defining an action for
unfair competition in the context of trademark infringement when the
plaintiff holds an unregistered mark). All content is copyright by
HollywoodInvestigator.com unless otherwise noted.